SEBI has issued a new circular (SEBI/HO/IMD/DF2/CIR/P/2016/42) on 18th March,2016 requesting Mutual Funds(MFs) to provide certain additional disclosures to its investors. A lot of people have already talked about the circular. For example here, here and here. The original circular itself can be found here.
The basic idea of the circular is that investors should have an idea of how much commission they are paying to the distributors. However this information alone won’t be of any help if the investors are not aware of any alternatives (read direct plans) to avoid paying those commissions. Hence the circular also mandates the funds to compare the standard with direct plan of the same scheme. Here SEBI is assuming that the investors will compare the commission paid by them with the service they are receiving from the adviser and accordingly decide whether to shift to direct plan or not. The negatives effects of this piece of regulation has already been discussed extensively in the above articles I have mentioned. However I beg to differ with those authors.
Earlier in 2009 when SEBI had banned front end loads of all mutual funds there was a similar hue and cry over how it will be detrimental to the development of industry. However this paper finds no evidence that the regulation has reduced inflow into mutual funds. Similarly when direct plans where introduced a lot of people were worried that distributors would be out of business. I think people might be over reacting to even the current regulation.
The circular also has requested funds to declare information regarding Fund manager’s name, his/her tenure and compensation; Board of directors, key personnel and Fund managers investment in the fund etc. Academic research has shown that these factors can affect fund performance. At first it might seem unrealistic that investors will use this information. But over time they will develop casual relationship between these variables and fund performance in their mind and use it subconsciously. Hence I don’t think it is a useless piece of regulation.
Only time will tell as to how this new regulation affects market but I am hopeful it won’t be as gloomy as others predict.